Author: Gerry Garing

Edition: Model Aviation - 2023/01
Page Numbers: 24, 25, 26, 27, 28
Static judges compare a scale model airplane with its documentation at the NASA Scale Classic.

2022 NASA SCALE CLASSIC

Popular Scale
event comes to a
new venue

By Gerry Garing
garingmg@verizon.net
Photos by Jack Neely

Static judges compare a scale model airplane with its documentation at the NASA Scale Classic.
Static judges Adam Grubb (L) and Bob Benson compare Dave Marenberg’s de Havilland Beaver with his documentation. Dave went on to fly to a first-place finish in Open at the NASA Scale Classic. Photos by Jack Neely
Three men pose with the Bob Lirette Award plaque outside the NASA Scale Classic venue.
The prestigious Bob Lirette Award was presented to Ron Hemphill (center), who is flanked by NASA Secretary and Contest Director, Gerry Garing (L), and NASA President Mike Barbee. Photos by Jack Neely

The Butler Aircraft Modelers Society (BAMS) of Butler, Pennsylvania, was selected to host the 2022 National Association of Scale Aeromodelers (NASA) Scale Classic contest on September 16-18, 2022. Here’s a little background about the two organizations.

NASA

In 1976, prolific Scale modeler Bob Underwood had the idea to form a group that could share information and promote the building and flying of Scale models. This group would represent and support Free Flight, Control Line (CL), and RC at the local, national, and international levels. With the encouragement of notable Scale modelers, including Claude McCullough, Dave Platt, Mike Gretz, and others, Bob proceeded with his dream and NASA was born.

NASA is a Special Interest Group of the AMA and, as such, is responsible for the AMA Scale Nats in both CL and RC. After a few years’ hiatus, NASA is again preparing to sponsor FAI CL and RC teams for the 2024 FAI F4 World Championships for Scale Model Aircraft.

Early morning view of a model aircraft flying field and pavilion
An early morning view of the pilots’ station, BAMS pavilion, and the flightline.

Sponsors
Aeroplane Art
Aircraft Documentation Services
National Balsa
Balsa USA
SI Models
Desert Aircraft
Sullivan Products
ElectroDynamics
TnT Landing Gear Products
Legend Hobby
Valley View RC
Micro Fasteners
Vogelsang Aeroscale
Nick Ziroli Plans
Wendell Hostetler Plans

BAMS

The BAMS club, founded in 1972, celebrated its 50th anniversary in the summer of 2022 at its beautiful flying site located in Western Pennsylvania, roughly 35 miles north of Pittsburgh. The BAMS club exemplifies the benefits of a partnership between model aviation and the community. Both the RC club and the Sylvania Conservation Area use the flying field and surrounding area.

In addition to the typical RC model activities, events throughout the year include entertaining residents from veteran and nursing facilities and hands-on educational experiences for groups, such as schools, churches, and the Boy and Girl Scouts. It offers a year-round meeting pavilion and model workshop with tools and a flight simulator. Real-time weather conditions are available from the on-site weather station.

What Is the NASA Scale Classic?

NASA sponsors regional CL and RC Scale contests throughout the year. These contests offer traditional AMA static-judged classes and Fun Scale. The NASA Scale Classic is held in different regional locations each fall as an invitational championship event based on performance at one or more of the regional contests.

An invitation to the NASA Scale Classic is earned by scoring within 90% of the top score during a regional contest. In line with NASA’s mission to encourage Scale modeling, Fun Scale classes are included and open to everyone. The Classic is often a combined CL and RC championship; however, 2022 was one of those years during which separate events were held.

The NASA Scale Classic offers all of the traditional AMA classes. The classes that include documented static judging required prequalification as noted. Any scalelike airplane that is built or bought an ARF, foamie, etc., qualifies for Fun Scale. New for 2022, Fun Scale Expert was divided into two divisions, separating high- and low-performance airplanes.

The Contest

Who could have guessed that a year in advance, when preparations began, that the event would be blessed with five straight days of perfect weather? Registration, static judging, and practice flying were on the menu for Friday. Static judges Bob Benson and Adam Grubb made the most of the 15 minutes allotted for comparing the models with the accompanying documentation. Models are judged from 15 feet away for accuracy of outline, color, markings, and craftsmanship.

Eight-foot banquet tables were fine years ago when models had 60- or 70-inch wingspans. Although not all of the airplanes are Giant Scale, the trend is in that direction, and it was challenging to safely position a 50-pound airplane with a 13-foot wingspan for front, side, and top views.

A mere .75 point separated the top three highest static scores. Jack Buckley earned 99.5 points and received the High Static score of the contest with his Designer Scale Fairchild 24. Expert Sport Scale entries of Mike Barbee’s King Air (99 points) and Larry Folk’s Top Cub (98.75 points) placed second and third.

Conditions were perfect and flying was nonstop throughout the day, to the delight of pilots and spectators alike. Pilots had a chance to acclimate to the field and sort out any problems before the first round of flying.

An extreme example was in midafternoon when Tim Dickey’s Fairchild PT-23 began making a strange sound and losing power. Not finding anything obvious, Tim disassembled the engine and discovered a broken rocker arm on the Robart radial engine. Knowing that he had spare that was back home in Arizona, he made a call to have the part shipped overnight to the hotel.

As the afternoon drew to a close, BAMS club members and their families treated everyone to a barbecue, complete with salads and dessert.

Let the Flying Begin

By 9 a.m. on Saturday, the light layer of fog burned off in time for the “Star-Spangled Banner” and the pilots’ meeting. Flight judging fell into the capable hands of Dale Arvin, Bob Benson, Jim Martin, and Rich Roberts, all of whom had previous experience judging NASA, AMA Nats, and/or Top Gun events.

The pilots took their places on the flightline and the contest was underway. As the first flights took to the air, Tim’s rocker arm arrived. He reassembled the engine and test-ran it in time to post a 98.25 first-round flight score and the highest of the entire contest.

Meanwhile, the spectators streamed in to be treated to Scale flying at its best. No cookie-cutter repetitive routines here! Whether it was a warbird, general aviation airplane, classic airplane, or aerobatic aircraft, each was flown in a realistic manner. It goes without saying that Mike Fearing’s turbine-powered Cougar was a crowd favorite. To the delight of the spectators, he added a few extra scalelike maneuvers, including a high-altitude vertical climb, all flown with perfection.

It seemed that the only class to be bitten by gremlins was Team Scale, and both instances were with landing gear. First, the muffler loosened midway through the round one flight on Carl Handley’s P-47 that was flown by Steve Eagle. The resulting dead-stick landing managed to bend the retractable landing gear.

Meanwhile, a brazed landing gear joint on Gerry Garing’s Piper Vagabond, flown by Jack Buckley, failed at the end of the round two’s landing rollout. Neither airplane had any significant damage, but there was enough to take them out of further contention.

There was little downtime between flights, which was made possible by the pilots who were always lined up and ready to go when it was their turn. As a result, three full rounds were completed by 4:30 Saturday afternoon. The contest scorekeeper, Tom Lowrie, became quite popular as each round concluded. Pilots crowded to see the scores and current standings from each class as they scrolled across the display monitor.

Pilots and staff were back at it early Sunday morning for the fourth and final round. Results were calculated, and by noon, it was time to announce winners, hand out awards, and head for home.

Bob Lirette Award

The flight judges determine the Bob Lirette Award, to be given to the person who best exemplifies Scale modeling during the contest. This year’s recipient was Ron Hemphill, who is a 45-year member of the BAMS. Ron has volunteered and competed at the Scale Nats and competed in the Mint Julep contest. His experience was invaluable in successfully coordinating the BAMS efforts with NASA’s needs. Additionally, he shared his time and experience to prepare and mentor a pilot through his first Scale contest. Congratulations, Ron!

Final Thoughts

It’s no secret that the model aircraft hobby has changed. Not that many years ago, competing in a contest meant that one had to build a competitive

NASA Raffle Winners
First Prize: Robert Culp: RTF Legend Hobby B-25 with JR radio system, DLE-20cc engines, A123 battery/switch setup, and Sullivan Products hardware

Second Prize: Brian Taylor: Desert Aircraft DA-80 engine

Third Prize: Dale Arvin: RV 4 plans, short kit, TnT landing gear, and documentation photo pack

Fokker D.VII model airplane
This Fokker D.VII, flown by Steve Eagle, took second place in Fun Scale Expert.

Scale model. Whether from a kit, plans, or scratch-built, it was a long-term commitment. RTF airplanes have all but taken over, to the point that many modelers don’t even realize it is possible to build a model! Although new modelers are brought in by ARFs, it is equally important to expose them to the exciting possibilities that exist.

The spectator turnout shows that interest in Scale aircraft exists. Spectators were restricted from the pit area; however, the airplanes were in view and pilots made sure to be accessible to interact and answer questions.

This year’s Scale Classic had two pilots with no previous contest experience who entered Fun Scale Novice. Every effort was made to ensure that these pilots were welcomed and mentored along the way. Each was teamed with an experienced caller to help them through their flights. Flight judges offered suggestions and tips after each flight.

The BAMS club did a remarkable job of preparing the field and facilities and promoting the event through local media. The Air Heritage Museum in Beaver, Pennsylvania, set up a display to promote its warbird museum, events, and wares.

Business was brisk for Hobby Express, in Cranberry, Pennsylvania, which brought a truckload of airplanes and hobby products for sale. A food truck and a popcorn maker were on hand to provide snacks and meals. Spectators were provided ballots to vote for their favorite airplane.

If we hope to promote the hobby and attract new modelers, events such as this can’t be held in isolation. Whether it is building a Scale model, flying a Scale model, or both, competitive Scale aeromodeling is a challenge that is much more than boring holes in the sky. Some modelers just don’t have any competitive interest and that’s fine. After all, this is a hobby.

For those who are thinking about trying it, there is no better time than now to get involved. NASA, AMA, and every other Scale aeromodeling organization is committed to attracting and retaining new blood into the sport. Give it a try!

Sources:

NASA
www.nasascale.org

BAMS
www.thebams.net

Contest Results

Fun Scale Novice

First: Mark Amisano, P-47
Second: Jeff Colussy, Corsair

Fun Scale Expert, Division 1

First: Mike Barbee, Stearman
Second: Steve Eagle, Fokker D.VII
Third: Bob Benson, Piper Cub

Fun Scale Expert, Division 2

First: Tom Lowrie, Acro Sport II
Second: Dave Marenberg, T-28
Third: Danny Carozza, Laser

Open Scale

First: Dave Marenberg, de Havilland Beaver
Second: Charles Gray, Piper Comanche
Third: Larry Folk, Ryan STA

Team Scale

First: Gerry Garing/Jack Buckley, Piper Vagabond
Second: Carl Handley/Steve Eagle, P-47

Designer Scale

First: Jack Buckley, Fairchild 24

Expert Sportsman

First: Mike Barbee, Beech King Air
Second: Tim Dickey, Fairchild PT-23
Third: Larry Folk, Top Cub

High Static Score: Jack Buckley, Fairchild 24
High Flight Score: Tim Dickey, Fairchild PT-23
Best Military: Tim Dickey, Fairchild PT-23
Best Civilian: Tom Lowrie, Acro Sport II

Spectators’ Choice: Mike Fearing, Grumman Cougar
Pilots’ Choice: Tim Dickey, Fairchild PT-23